I am not going to bother with mentioning Scott. I'll leave that to my "comments" section.

I will say no more.

Anwar was too much of a contradiction; Squeaky clean school teacher with the dreads of a Rasta....

I'm pretty sure the final four were all standing on the same side of the stage...how about Bo splitting the middle last night? I thought he did well in a bad situation, and why would they put him in such a spot anyway?

Scott, Scott, Scott....he's got to be next, the Clay clone will go shortly after him, and then, hmm, Vonzell and then Constantine ( I reserve the right to exchange Carrie in this position if she doesn't fix her wardrobe and presentation problems - when will these contestants learn to listen to Simon ? Don't they realize he is who they will work for? )

Bo wins it all and Carrie becomes the next Leann Rimes....

I thought he did well in a bad situation, and why would they put him in such a spot anyway?

Drama, they like to create drama! I thought he did the right thing too!

Scott, no more comments. I guess America will try to prove that he can win. Blech!

Vonzell leaving early, no way! I say, Scott, then Anthony.

That will leave Vonzell, Carrie, Constantine and Bo as the top four. And I say, Bo and Constantine will be duking it out. Although I love Vonzell, I don't think she stands a chance to win this one. I hope I'm proven wrong and it will be between she and Bo! (fingers crossed ! )

That will leave Vonzell, Carrie, Constantine and Bo as the top four. And I say, Bo and Constantine will be duking it out. Although I love Vonzell, I don't think she stands a chance to win this one. I hope I'm proven wrong and it will be between she and Bo! (fingers crossed ! )

I would dig a Vonzell/ Bo final.  They're my favorite two.  (Vonzell has replaced Nadia as my favorite woman in the competition.)

I wondered if I should have swapped Anthony with Vonzell in my last prediction.

I think Anwar leaving and Constantine staying, shows that it isn't all about the singing. It's wierd. At the start of the competition I would have thought Constantine would leave early, yet he has a big possibility of being in the top 3 or 4. I personally want Carrie to win, but I think her personality doesn't come through as much as Vonzell.

Next week? I think Scott has enough fans and luck to pull him through, which means Anthony will be the one to be eliminated next week. With the final four it will be difficult, both Carrie and Constantine has never been in the bottom 3, so my guess is Vonzell, but it does sound like she's gaining more fans as the week passes.

Constantine = Jasmine Trias? Vonzell = Fantasia? Bo = Latoya?

Jamie, I remember a few weeks ago, you said you would like Scott no matter what he sings. Has that change cause he is getting worse? or just simply he isn't as good as the others?

Jamie, I remember a few weeks ago, you said you would like Scott no matter what he sings.

I'd be surprised if I said this exactly, but I was higher on him than most everyone else at the start.  I felt that he had a good chance and sort of an "everyman-type" appeal.  I didn't think he'd win, but I didn't expect him to play the "John Stevens" role either.

You're right however that I have soured on him quite a bit due to his recent performances.

I am the most surprised with Constantine.  I thought that he'd be long gone by now!

Scott wins...idol is done forever!!

There is a reason why I begin every Idol article with "Click here to read my latest article."

I doubt anyone will read a comment on such an old post.

arrrhhhhhhhhhhh ........ its gonna be time scott and anthony gets eliminated .............. i dun think bo stands a chance in the finale

i want the vonz to win because she has it all!!!