Carrie Underwood wins
Published on May 25, 2005 By Jamie Burnside In Entertainment

Tonight's final episode of season four gave us a moment of TV serendipity.  In one hour, on the same show, we saw both Kenny G. and David Hasselhoff.  (Conan O'Brien must be happy today.)  As a bit of icing-on-the-top, Hall and Oates were in the audience as well.

The show itself was fantastic.  It had more of a "showcase" feel to it than past seasons' final shows.  I hope that they stick with this format in subsequent seasons.

Tonight's highlights:

  1. Dirk (nerdy comedian audition-guy) got to sit next to his hero, David Hasselhoff.  I really marked-out for that one!  When Ryan introduced the hunky Baywatch star, I was really surprised.
  2. There was a replay of Leroy Wells' audition.  That was awesome!  (Seeing Gene Simmons at the table, I am hoping that they bring him back in some capacity next year.  He was one of the best things about this season.)  I may have to go back in my audition tapes and watch Leroy do his thing again.  That was arguably the most entertaining moment of the whole series.  (That, and Mario stating that he wasn't bald.)
  3. There was a really good pre-produced parody on the Corey Clarke interview.  Randy, Simon, Paula, Ryan, and William Hung played prominent roles.  I was impressed.
  4. All of the top-twelve performers had the chance to sing onstage with some established stars.  Looking at the second- and third- season runners-up in the audience, I was thinking that they would have liked to have that opportunity.  Vonzell put on a really good performance from atop a grand piano.

In the end, Carrie Underwood was named American Idol.  I was mildly surprised, but honestly she needed the win more than Bo.  (Just like Ruben needed the win more than Clay did.)

Tonight's show put a really good veneer on the season as a whole.  It was good enough that I am once again anticipating the next round of auditions.  A showcase like this was just what the series needed to help avoid the final impression of the series getting stale.  This final show rejuvenated the series.

That's all for this year.  Thanks for reading my blog.

-Jamie


Comments
on May 25, 2005
&*^@#&#%^%!!! BO WAS ROBBED!!!!!

 Kenny G ... David Hasselhoff ... Hall and Oates ... Carrie Underwood


That's about right.
on May 26, 2005
I thought the show itself wasw very entertaining. I loved it that the one lady sand the national anthem. The two nerds being with David Hasselhoff, priceless. Leroy's audition, much fun.

I agree, Gene Simmons should come back. I actually liked Vonzell a lot more last night than I did during the season.

I am disappointed that Bo didn't win, but I thought the same thing this morning, Bo doesn't need it. She does.

Thanks for the blog Jamie...
Till next season...


P.S. Can we talk you into a "Hell's Kitchen" blog!? **
on May 26, 2005

P.S. Can we talk you into a "Hell's Kitchen" blog!? **

Somehow I am really looking forward to that show.  I may comment on it, but I don't know whether I will do full recaps.  (That is quite a commitment!)

However, those lesser-known shows seem to bring a lot of traffic to this weblog.  If you look at my "Top Articles", the number two article is one about WB Superstar (which I also recapped).  It even edges out my top ranked American Idol article.  Weird...

on May 26, 2005
I see the conspiracy now , Bo really didn't need the win, he'll do well in the "Clay position"....

Looking for Carrie's premiere on CMT !!!!!

Here's another vote for Gene Simons to be a regular next season ( I bet he earns a sexual harrassment charge....refer back to his "Apprentice" cameo as an example )

Thanks again for thr reviews..
on May 26, 2005
I'm disappointed too that Bo didn't get the title. But perhaps you and others are right, Carrie needed the win more. Bo will be a superstar regardless! I'ld definately buy his CD I don't think I'ld buy Carrie's.

Thanks again for the recap and reviews Jamie. I might tune in to the Hell's Kitchen show too. Heck, I'll watch the first one to see if it's worth watching!
on May 26, 2005
Can you tell me the name of the song Vonzell sang last night? I was crying after the first two lines and have been searching all morning for the song title.
on May 26, 2005

I will look it up on my tape when I get home from work tonight.  I know that I recognized the song. 

Any helpers out there?

on May 26, 2005
Vonzell sang the beautiful song called "With You I'm Born Again"
Mariah Carey and John Legend also sang a wonderful rendition of the song on VH1's Save The Music if you look out for the reruns.
on May 26, 2005
Conspirarcy aside, I'm not sure if I am surprise or not.

On one hand, we have the Bo-phenomena, where he cant get enough praise for everything he's ever done. He's weakest moments are still strong let down only by boring song choices, but consistent performances and vocal. He's strongest moments is probably the strongest out of all the idols.

Then there's Carrie, with a very strong pure voice and country twang. She has more fans than any other idols this season; she has never been in the bottom three at all - even through her weakest moments. Apart from your comments Jamie (and other comments here), other blogs and comments from other websites supported Carrie more than Bo.

Personally, I am glad Carrie has won, although Bo probably deserves to win it. Is Carrie more marketable than Bo. Carrie's and Vonzell's albums are the ones I will be buying. Again thanks Jamie for your comments and insight. I will see you next year.
on May 27, 2005
Okay that WAS really weird. Carrie singing Angels brought me here was totally totally weird and I didn't like it that much.
on May 29, 2005
Sad that Bo didn't win . But I understand the reasoning behind him not having to win...looking forward to hearing what his and Carrie's CDs will be like.
on May 30, 2005
Jamie, You did another great job with your reviews this season. I didn't watch the show but I read your AI posts regularly. I felt like I really kept up with things because of your insightful comments. Who needs to spend hours watching the show when you can just read Jamie's blog, I say!

Great job!
Nancy